Stonehill College

Sheeler holds Stonehill's career record with 402 tackles over his time on the gridiron from 2000-03. He also holds the school record with 53.5 career tackles for a loss and stands second with 230 career unassisted tackles. Sheeler recovered eight fumbles during his time at Stonehill, good for third in the record books. During his senior campaign, the All-Northeast 10 linebacker recorded 128 tackles, good for second-most in a single season in Stonehill history.